Dental news
Dentistry News | Dental Jobs | Dentist Forum | CPD Education

Learning from the pilot

26th Sep 2011

Email this story
Email this story
  
Share this story
Digg it submit to reddit printer-friendly version

The media coverage of the launch of the dental contract pilots on 1 September was really positive. It was really good to see dentistry portrayed in such an upbeat way.
 
Any payment system will have inherent incentives within it and our challenge is to minimise the negative and maximise the opportunities to drive positive ways of working. The history of dental payments in this country has shown us many of the risks.
 
The government is committed to a focus on quality and capitation and this is central to the construction of the pilots. Within this framework ,we hope to gather the learning that will help us to address how to construct a balanced system of financial incentives
 
A huge amount of work has gone into the development of these pilots. Their aim is to allow us to test out different aspects of a possible new contract. The early signs are good.

I have visited many practices involved in the process and the enthusiasm for the culture change, where reward is based on quality of outcome as well as numbers of patients, underpinned  by a care pathway approach, is encouraging.

Advertisement

I myself was involved in the piloting of capitation for adults between 1998-2002 and understand the potential for positive outcomes but this is complex work and we need to ensure that the process is evaluated robustly.
 
The system needs to deliver for all parties, for dentists a fair income and reasonable workload  which allows them to deliver high quality care to their patients. For the public, the need to have confidence that the system offers them security of access to care that delivers good oral health and for the taxpayer they need to have confidence that the system delivers these outcomes whilst at the same time offering value for money.
 
Having successfully developed legislation to make the pilots legal and supported providers and the NHS in agreeing local variations to contracts, the focus is now moving towards drawing out the learning and high quality evaluation of the pilots and then further engagement in implementing the lessons learnt.
 
For me personally, it was good to see dentists presenting such a positive image of the profession and really engaging in the process.
 
The significant improvement in overall access to services over the last couple of years has not attracted major media interest but the media interest in the improvement in the delivery of evidence-based prevention has been really good and will play a significant part in educating the public as to what they should expect from a quality NHS dental service.
 
My deputy, Sue, and I are hoping to visit all the pilots over the next few months and the direct feedback we will receive is an important part of the exciting development process we are now engaged in.

Author

Barry Cockcroft


Barry Cockcroft is chief dental officer for England – and an ardent Bolton Wanderers fan.

Rate this story


Comments

avatar placeholder
Now if I remember correctly, he was praising the "Nectar Point" system the same way just a few years back. New political masters = more spin and rubbish from the CDO.
Now the Nirvana of NHS dentistry will be reached with "Denplan on the cheap" !
Posted by Expat 26/09/11 at 21:16
'New boss, same as old boss!' If you pay peanuts, you get monkeys. I'll stay with 'real Denplan', thanks very much Bazza......
Posted by docholliday 26/09/11 at 21:23
doc -how about james and bobby purify- "pull them little strings and I'll sing you a song-I'm your puppet" Admittedly you have to be a certain age to remember that one. Wht price integrity?
Posted by gordie 27/09/11 at 07:46
Googled it gordie.......ha ha! Still in short trousers at primary school in 1966. Might be in my Mums' record collection in the attic somewhere......
Posted by docholliday 27/09/11 at 08:56
avatar placeholder
Capitation has been tried before and it didnt work , once in the 1990s for children and then with the first PDS contracts in 2004/2005 . What makes the DoH think that it will work again because its been linked to KPIs ( key performance indicators ) that will fail to measure quality of work . In fact Mr Cockcrofts pilot that he mentioned failed to impress the DoH so much that it wasnt rolled out for everyone. Its time for the DoH to realise that there is no ideal system to provide NHS dentistry and listen to the dentists that provide the NHS treatment not some dry fingered professor that works part time in an ivory tower .
Posted by thetoothdoc 27/09/11 at 13:52
Please log-in to post comments or register here.



Search
Members' Area
Remember me    Register free | Forgotten password

What are we electing?
The DH may well say 'Who do I call if I want to speak to the BDA?'
View all blogs

Advertisement